48%
of salespeople never follow up. Not even once.
80% of sales close after the 5th follow-up. Think about that gap. Half the people quit after one try, but the deals are closing after five or more touches.
That "no" you got? That wasn't a no — that was "not yet."
Educate Follow-Ups
Every follow-up must do one of three things: educate, validate, or add value. If it doesn't, don't send it.
- A short video on S-corp structure for their specific situation
- A tax deadline reminder with implications they hadn't considered
- A surprising stat — "Did you know 62% of contractors overpay their taxes?"
Validate Follow-Ups
Social proof is the most powerful persuasion tool you have. Use it in every follow-up sequence.
- A testimonial from a client in a similar industry or situation
- A case study with specific numbers and outcomes
- A screenshot of a real result — tax savings, revenue growth, etc.
Value-Add Follow-Ups
The more you give without asking, the more they feel compelled to reciprocate.
- A $5 Starbucks gift card with a thoughtful note
- A relevant article or industry report
- A quick insight specific to their business — something only you'd notice
The litmus test: before you send any follow-up, ask yourself — does this educate, validate, or add value? If the answer is no, delete it and start over.
"Just checking in..."
"Quick question..."
"Following up on my last email..."
"Wanted to circle back..."
Your Competitor
- "Hey, just checking in to see if you had any questions about our proposal..."
You
- A 60-second Loom video explaining a tax strategy specific to their situation
The law of reciprocity: every interaction should leave them feeling like they owe you because of the value you gave. That's how you follow up without sounding needy — you make them grateful you reached out.
Step 1: Text
"Great speaking with you! I just sent a recap to your inbox with next steps and some resources I mentioned."
Step 2: Email
Full recap of what you discussed, clear next steps, relevant resources, and your availability.
Do this whether they said yes, no, or maybe. You're demonstrating the communication standard they'll get as a client. This is the reason they're leaving their current CPA — because their CPA doesn't communicate like this.
-
1Monday — Discovery Call
-
2Wednesday — Proposal Call
-
3Next Monday — Onboarding
4 days. Start to finish. Most accountants let this drag out over weeks. The prospect goes cold, talks to competitors, or does nothing. Compress the timeline and hesitation dies.
Before — $10K/month
- Extended timelines, cold leads
- Proposals sent by email
- Waiting weeks for decisions
After — $30K/month
- Proposal calls + 4-day close
- Momentum replaced hesitation
- Same leads, same offer, same market
Alexis tripled her revenue by making one change: compressing the timeline from weeks to days.
-
1Nurture Sequence — Route them into your email nurture so they stay warm and keep seeing your expertise
-
2Value-Add Check-ins — Touch base at 30, 60, and 90 days with something useful — not a pitch
-
3Play the Long Game — The lead you nurture today might be a $15K client in 6 months
No lead should ever fall through the cracks. When someone says "not now," have a clear process for where they go and how you stay in touch.
Follow-up is not about persistence. It's about generosity.
When you approach every follow-up as an opportunity to give — to teach, to prove, to help — you will never sound needy. And when they're ready, you'll be the only person they want to work with.
Build Your Follow-Up Sequence
Write a 5-touch sequence with one educate, one validate, and one value-add piece. Map out the timing between each touch.
Create Your Double-Tap Templates
Write your post-call text message and recap email templates. Make them easy to personalize quickly.
Write Your "Never Say" List
List the 5 phrases you'll eliminate from every follow-up. Write what you'll say instead.
Define Your Nurture Handoff
Set up your process for routing "not now" leads to long-term nurture. Define the 30/60/90-day check-in cadence.
These aren't optional — they're the systems that will keep your pipeline from leaking. Complete all four exercises before moving on. Go follow up like a professional.